Division II
Individual Records
| Goals in a Game | ||||
| Cameron Holding | Grand Valley State | 11 | vs. Sam Houston State | 2011 |
| Raymond Vasilas | Eckerd | 10 | vs. Utah Valley | 2006 |
| Shawn Beer | Davenport | 8 | vs. Briarcliffe | 2011 |
| Shawn Beer | Davenport | 8 | vs. Utah Valley | 2011 |
| Cameron Holding | Grand Valley State | 8 | vs. Southwestern | 2008 |
| Cameron Holding | Grand Valley State | 8 | vs. Westminster | 2008 |
| Assists in a Game | ||||
| Jordan Richtsmeier | Davenport | 7 | vs. Concordia | 2012 |
| Jonathan Bonacore | Briarcliffe | 7 | vs. Hope | 2011 |
| Jack Dumsa | Grand Valley State | 7 | vs. SCAD | 2011 |
| Jack Dumsa | Grand Valley State | 7 | vs. Sam Houston State | 2011 |
| James Nebeker | Westminster | 6 | vs. Emory | 2007 |
| Brian Strauss | St. John's | 6 | vs. Dayton | 2007 |
| Points in a Game | ||||
| Jack Dumsa | Grand Valley State | 12 | vs. Sam Houston State | 2011 |
| Cameron Holding | Grand Valley State | 12 | vs. Sam Houston State | 2011 |
| Cameron Holding | Grand Valley State | 12 | vs. Southwestern | 2008 |
| Raymond Vasilas | Eckerd | 12 | vs. Utah Valley | 2006 |
| Jonathan Bonacore | Briarcliffe | 11 | vs. Hope | 2011 |
| Matt Carp | Briarcliffe | 11 | vs. Hope | 2011 |
| Jack Dumsa | Grand Valley State | 11 | vs. SCAD | 2011 |
| Saves in a Game | ||||
| Austin Dover | St. Thomas | 26 | vs. Lourdes | 2016 |
| Connor Kelley | Southern Oregon | 26 | vs. Dayton | 2016 |
| Dallas McLellan | Westminster | 23 | vs. Elon | 2010 |
| Jacob Dickson | Southwestern | 22 | vs. San Diego | 2005 |
| Ryan Mailloux | Siena Heights | 22 | Missouri Valley | 2015 |
| Connor Mishler | Lourdes | 22 | St. Thomas | 2016 |
| Dallas McLellan | Westminster | 21 | vs. St. Thomas | 2011 |
| Michael Candler | Sam Houston State | 20 | vs. Coast Guard | 2013 |
| Ben Hughes | Missouri Baptist | 20 | vs. St. John's | 2011 |
| Hunter Billings | Rhode Island | 20 | vs. Montana | 2022 |
Team Records
| Goals in a Game | |||
| Dayton | 27 | vs. Sam Houston State | 2012 |
| Grand Valley State | 25 | vs. Sam Houston State | 2011 |
| Davenport | 23 | vs. Briarcliffe | 2011 |
| Davenport | 23 | vs. Utah Valley | 2011 |
| Grand Valley State | 23 | vs. Southwestern | 2008 |
| Goals in a Tournament | ||
| Davenport | 76 | 2011 |
| St. Thomas | 72 | 2016 |
| St. Thomas | 67 | 2010 |
| Grand Valley State | 62 | 2011 |
| St. Thomas | 60 | 2019 |
| Rhode Island | 53 | 2022 |
| Concordia-Irvine | 52 | 2017 |
| Dayton | 52 | 2015 |
| Dayton | 52 | 2012 |
| Goals per Game Average | (3 game min.) | ||
| Grand Valley State | 20.6 | 62 goals in 3 games | 2011 |
| Davenport | 19.0 | 76 goals in 4 games | 2011 |
| St. Thomas | 18.0 | 72 goals in 4 games | 2016 |
| Dayton | 17.3 | 52 goals in 3 games | 2012 |
| St. Thomas | 16.8 | 67 goals in 4 games | 2010 |
| St. Thomas | 16.6 | 50 goals in 3 games | 2009 |
| Fewest Goals Allowed in a Game | |||
| St. Thomas | 1 | vs. Missouri State | 2017 |
| St. Thomas | 2 | vs. Missouri State | 2018 |
| San Diego | 2 | vs. Southwestern | 2005 |
| Numerous times | 3 | Latest: St. Thomas vs. UCSD | 2019 |
| Fewest Goals Allowed Average | (3 game min.) | ||
| San Diego | 3.66 | 11 goals in 3 games | 2005 |
| San Diego | 4 | 12 goals in 3 games | 2006 |
| St. Thomas | 4.75 | 19 goals in 4 games | 2018 |
| Most Tournament Championships | ||
| St. Thomas | 6 | 2009, 2010, 2012, 2013, 2016, 2019 |
| San Diego | 2 | 2005, 2006 |
| Dayton | 2 | 2015, 2023 |
| North Dakota State | 1 | 2018 |
| Concordia-Irvine | 1 | 2017 |
| Grand Valley State | 1 | 2014 |
| Davenport | 1 | 2011 |
| Westminster | 1 | 2008 |
| Montana | 1 | 2007 |
| Utah | 1 | 2022 |
| Most Championship Game Appearances | ||
| St. Thomas | 10 | 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2023 |
| Grand Valley State | 4 | 2008, 2012, 2014, 2016 |
| St. John's | 3 | 2006, 2007, 2014 |
| Dayton | 3 | 2009, 2015, 2019 |
| Utah Valley | 2 | 2005, 2010 |
| San Diego | 2 | 2005, 2006 |
| Westminster | 2 | 2008, 2013 |
| Concordia (Calif.) | 2 | 2015, 2017 |
| North Dakota State | 1 | 2018 |
| Davenport | 1 | 2011 |
| Montana | 1 | 2007 |
| Utah | 1 | 2022 |
| Rhode Island | 1 | 2022 |
Yearly Results
2005 - Blaine, Minnesota
Quarterfinals
No. 1 San Diego 22, No. 8 Southwestern 2
No. 2 Utah Valley 8, No. 7 Calvin 7 (OT)
No. 6 Harding 11, No. 3 Davidson 3
No. 4 Montana 13, No. 5 St. John’s 8
Semifinals
No. 1 San Diego 16, No. 4 Montana 3
No. 2 Utah Valley 12, No. 6 Harding 8
Championship
No. 1 San Diego 9, No. 2 Utah Valley 6
2006 - Plano, Texas
First Round
No. 5 Montana 19, No. 12 Southwestern 3
No. 6 St. John’s 9, No. 11 Harding 7
No. 7 Eckerd 18, No. 10 Augustana 10
No. 8 Northern Colorado 7, No. 9 Calvin 6 (OT)
Quarterfinals
No. 1 San Diego 14, No. 8 Northern Colorado 3
No. 7 Eckerd 22, No. 2 Utah Valley 10
No. 6 St. John’s 8, No. 3 St. Thomas 7
No. 5 Montana 11, No. 4 Claremont 7
Semifinals
No. 1 San Diego 8, No. 5 Montana 6
No. 6 St. John’s 10, No. 7 Eckerd 9
Championship
No. 1 San Diego 10, No. 6 St. John’s 3
2007 - Frisco, Texas
First Round
No. 5 Dayton 14, No. 12 UC Irvine 5
No. 6 Northern Colorado 9, No. 11 Southwestern 4
No. 7 Emory 19, No. 10 Fort Lewis 13
No. 8 Harding 13, No. 9 Western Washington 10
Quarterfinals
No. 1 St. John’s 12, No. 8 Harding 6
No. 2 Westminster 12, No. 7 Emory 9
No. 3 Montana 13, No. 6 Northern Colorado 8
No. 5 Dayton 10, No. 4 St. Thomas 8
Semifinals
No. 1 St. John’s 14, No. 5 Dayton 4
No. 3 Montana 19, No. 2 Westminster 18
Championship
No. 3 Montana 15, No. 1 St. John’s 5
2008 - Farmer’s Branch & Irving, Texas
First Round
No. 5 Dayton 15, No. 12 UC Santa Cruz 8
No. 6 Elon 17, No. 11 Framingham State 5
No. 10 Southwestern 12, No. 7 Fort Lewis 8
No. 8 Western Oregon 21, No. 9 Harding 5
Quarterfinals
No. 1 Westminster 20, No. 8 Western Oregon 9
No. 2 Grand Valley State 23, No. 10 Southwestern 13
No. 3 St. Thomas 19, No. 6 Elon 10
No. 5 Dayton 17, No. 4 St. John’s 9
Semifinals
No. 1 Westminster 10, No. 5 Dayton 6
No. 2 Grand Valley State 13, No. 3 St. Thomas 11
Championship
No. 1 Westminster 17, No. 2 Grand Valley State 10
2009 - Denver, Colorado
First Round
No. 5 Northern Colorado 14, No. 12 Stonehill 9
No. 6 Emory 13, No. 11 Cal State Fullerton 5
No. 7 Westminster 8, No. 10 Missouri State 7
No. 9 Western Oregon 9, No. 8 Southwestern 8
Quarterfinals
No. 1 Dayton 14, No. 9 Western Oregon 9
No. 2 St. Thomas 16, No. 7 Westminster 5
No. 3 Davenport 12, No. 6 Emory 10
No. 4 St. John’s 13, No. 5 Northern Colorado 9
Semifinals
No. 1 Dayton 10, No. 4 St. Johns 9 (OT)
No. 2 St. Thomas 18, No. 3 Davenport 7
Championship
No. 2 St. Thomas 16, No. 1 Dayton 11
2010 - Denver, Colorado
First Round
No. 1 St. Thomas 22, No. 16 Sam Houston State 3
No. 2 Dayton 14, No. 15 Missouri State 3
No. 3 Utah Valley 10, No. 14 Briarcliffe 9
No. 4 Grand Valley State 15, No. 13 Cal State Fullerton 4
No. 5 Davenport 11, No. 12 Western Washington 8
No. 6 St. John’s 7, No. 11 SCAD 4
No. 10 Westminster 11, No. 7 Elon 7
No. 9 Grove City 11, No. 8 Western Oregon 8
Quarterfinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 16, No. 9 Grove City 6
No. 10 Westminster 14, No. 2 Dayton 11
No. 3 Utah Valley 9, No. 6 St. John’s 8
No. 5 Davenport 6, No. 4 Grand Valley State 5
Semifinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 17, No. 5 Davenport 9
No. 3 Utah Valley 9, No. 10 Westminster 7
Championship
No. 1 St. Thomas 12, No. 3 Utah Valley 9
2011 - Denver, Colorado
First Round
No. 1 Grand Valley State 25, No. 16 Sam Houston State 7
No. 2 St. Thomas 17, No. 15 Cal State Fullerton 3
No. 3 St. John’s 12, No. 14 Missouri Baptist 5
No. 4 Briarcliffe 21, No. 13 Hope 14
No. 5 Davenport 23, No. 12 Utah Valley 9
No. 6 Dayton 14, No. 11 Northern Colorado 8
No. 10 Westminster 20, No. 7 Western Oregon 15
No. 9 SCAD 10, No. 8 North Dakota State 8
Quarterfinals
No. 1 Grand Valley State 22, No. 9 SCAD 13
No. 2 St. Thomas 9, No. 10 Westminster 7
No. 6 Dayton 15, No. 3 St. John’s 8
No. 5 Davenport 23, No. 4 Briarcliffe 10
Semifinals
No. 5 Davenport 16, No. 1 Grand Valley State 15 (OT)
No. 2 St. Thomas 12, No. 6 Dayton 11
Championship
No. 5 Davenport 14, No. 1 St. Thomas 9
2012 - Greenville, South Carolina
First Round
No. 1 St. Thomas 11, No. 16 Western Oregon 6
No. 2 Grand Valley State 18, No. 15 Washington-St. Louis 5
No. 3 Westminster 12, No. 14 Saint Mary's 6
No. 4 Dayton 27, No. 13 Sam Houston State 8
No. 5 St. John's 6, No. 12 Elon 4
No. 6 Davenport 10, No. 11 Concordia 12
No. 10 Grand Canyon 6, No. 7 SCAD 5 (OT)
No. 9 North Dakota State 12, No. 8 Briarcliffe 11 (OT)
Quarterfinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 10, No. 9 North Dakota State 7
No. 2 Grand Valley State 10, No. 10 Grand Canyon 8
No. 6 Davenport 12, No. 3 Westminster 11
No. 4 Dayton 12, No. 5 St. John's 4
Semifinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 14, No. 4 Dayton 13
No. 2 Grand Valley State 15, No. 6 Davenport 11
Championship
No. 1 St. Thomas 9, No. 2 Grand Valley State 8
2013 - Greenville, South Carolina
First Round
No. 1 St. Thomas 11, No. 16 DePaul 3
No. 2 Westminster 16, No. 15 Briarcliffe 4
No. 3 St. John’s 15, No. 14 Western Oregon 8
No. 4 Liberty 12, No. 13 North Dakota State 11
No. 12 Grove City 12, No. 5 Concordia 9
No. 6 Grand Valley State 6, No. 11 SCAD 5
No. 10 Indiana Tech 20, No. 7 Palm Beach Atlantic 10
No. 9 Coast Guard 19, No. 8 Sam Houston State 8
Quarterfinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 18, No. 9 Coast Guard 8
No. 2 Westminster 15, No. 10 Indiana Tech 6
No. 3 St. John’s 10, No. 6 Grand Valley State 8
No. 4 Liberty 10, No. 12 Grove City 9
Semifinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 10, No. 4 Liberty 9 (OT)
No. 2 Westminster 9, No. 3 St. John’s 8 (OT)
Championship
No. 1 St. Thomas 9, No. 2 Westminster 7
2014 – Irvine & Orange, California
First Round
No. 1 Grand Valley 13, No. 16 Montana State 8
No. 2 St. John’s 13, No. 15 Missouri Valley 10
No. 3 Dayton 12, No. 14 Coast Guard 9
No. 4 St. Thomas 13, No. 13 Reinhardt 6
No. 5 North Dakota State 19, No. 12 Concordia (Calif.) 7
No. 6 Grove City 11, No. 11 Western Washington 10
No. 7 Indiana Tech 10, No. 10 Florida Gulf Coast 9
No. 8 Western Oregon 13, No. 9 SCAD 11
Quarterfinals
No. 1 Grand Valley State 13, No. 8 Western Oregon 5
No. 2 St. John’s 13, No. 7 Indiana Tech 6
No. 3 Dayton 10, No. 6 Grove City 7
No. 4 St. Thomas 8, No. 5 North Dakota State 6
Semifinals
No. 1 Grand Valley State 10, No. 4 St. Thomas 5
No. 2 St. John’s 14, No. 3 Dayton 9
Championship
No. 1 Grand Valley State 12, No. 2 St. John’s 11
2015 – Irvine & Orange, California
First Round
No. 1 Concordia (Calif.) 16, No. 16 Briarcliffe 11
No. 2 St. Thomas 21, No. 15 Utah State 14
No. 14 Siena Heights 8, No. 3 Missouri Valley 7
No. 4 North Dakota State 13, No. 13 Sierra Nevada 8
No. 12 Western Washington 10, No. 5 Grand Valley State 9
No. 6 Dayton 20, No. 11 Kennesaw State 6
No. 7 Florida Gulf Coast 9, No. 10 Cal State Fullerton 8
No. 8 St. John’s 15, No. 9 Grove City 13
Quarterfinals
No. 1 Concordia (Calif.) 14, No. 8 St. John’s 12
No. 2 St. Thomas 16, No. 7 Florida Gulf Coast 6
No. 12 Western Washington 12, No. North Dakota State 11
No. 6 Dayton 7, No. 14 Siena Heights 6
Semifinals
No. 1 Concordia (Calif.) 15, No. 12 Western Washington 8
No. 6 Dayton 13, No. 2 St. Thomas 12
Championship
No. 6 Dayton 12, No. 1 Concordia 11
2016 – Irvine & Orange, California
First Round
No. 1 St. Thomas 19, No. 16 Bridgewater State 7
No. 2 Dayton 18, No. 15 Southern Oregon 3
No. 3 Concordia (Calif.) 15, No. 14 Montana State 12
No. 4 North Dakota State 13, No. 13 Sierra Nevada 7
No. 5 Kennesaw State 7, No. 12 Siena Heights 6
No. 6 Grand Valley State 13, No. 11 Missouri Valley 7
No. 7 Reinhardt 9, No. 10 Grove City 8
No. 8 Lourdes 11, No. 9 Minn.-Duluth 10
Quarterfinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 20, No. 8 Lourdes 14
No. 7 Reinhardt 9, No. 2 Dayton 8
No. 6 Grand Valley State 8, No. 3 Concordia (Calif.) 7
No. 4 North Dakota State 10, No. 5 Kennesaw State 4
Semifinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 13, No. 4 North Dakota State 9
No. 6 Grand Valley State 15, No. 7 Reinhardt 9
Championship
No. 1 St. Thomas 10, No. 6 Grand Valley State 7
2017 – Irvine & Orange, California
First Round
No. 1 St. Thomas 15, No. 16 Missouri State 1
No. 2 Concordia-Irvine 18, No. 15 Louisiana 4
No. 3 Sierra Nevada 18, No. 14 Palm Beach Atlantic 6
No. 4 Dayton 17, No. 13 Montana 7
No. 5 Grand Valley State 11, No. 12 Bridgewater 6
No. 6 North Dakota State 13, No. 11 Metro State 8
No. 7 St. John's 10, No. 10 Cal State Fullerton 9
No. 8 Minn.-Duluth 9, No. 9 Florida Gulf Coast 3
Quarterfinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 11, No. 8 Minn.-Duluth 7
No. 2 Concorida-Irvine 10, No. 7 St. John's 9
No. 6 North Dakota State 9, No. 3 Sierra Nevada 8
No. 5 Grand Valley State 10, No. 4 Dayton 9
Semifinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 14, No. 5 Grand Valley State 12
No. 2 Concordia-Irvine 11, No. No. 6 North Dakota State 9
Championship
No. 2 Concordia-Irvine 13, No. 1 St. Thomas 10
2018 – Salt Lake City
First Round
No. 1 St. Thomas 16, No. 16 Missouri State 2
No. 2 North Dakota State 10, No. 15 Central Conn. State 4
No. 3 Minn.-Duluth 22, No. 14 College of Idaho 8
No. 4 St. John's 18, No. 13 UC Davis 3
No. 5 Grand Valley State 14, No. 12 Cal State San Marcos 9
No. 6 Kennesaw State 11, No. 11 Cal State Fullerton 7
No. 7 Montana State 17, No. 10 Dayton 11
No. 9 Florida Gulf Coast 7, No. 8 Sierra Nevada 5
Quarterfinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 6, No. 9 Florida Gulf Coast 4
No. 2 North Dakota State 12, No. 7 Montana State 6
No. 3 Minn.-Duluth 16, No. 6 Kennesaw State 4
No. 5 Grand Valley State 11, No. 4 St. John's 9
Semifinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 14, No. 5 Grand Valley State 5
No. 2 North Dakota State 11, No. 3 Minn.-Duluth 8
Championship
No. 2 North Dakota State 8, No. 1 St. Thomas 7 (2ot)
2019 – Salt Lake City
First Round
No. 1 Minn.-Duluth 15, No. 16 Bridgewater State 7
No. 2 St. Thomas 17, No. 15 UC San Diego 3
No. 3 Grand Valley State 14, No. 14 Missouri State 6
No. 4 Dayton 10, No. 13 Montana 7
No. 5 North Florida 13, No. 12 Utah State 8
No. 6 College of Idaho 18, No. 11 Northern Arizona 11
No. 10 St. John's 10, No. 7 Kennesaw State 9
No. 8 North Dakota State 12, No. 9 UC Davis 3
Quarterfinals
No. 8 North Dakota State 16, No. 1 Minn.-Duluth 14
No. 2 St. Thomas 16, No. 10 St. John's 8
No. 6 College of Idaho 13, No. 3 Grand Valley State 9
No. 4 Dayton 10, No. 5 North Florida 7
Semifinals
No. 4 Dayton 11, No. 8 North Dakota State 9
No. 2 St. Thomas 18, No. 6 College of Idaho 7
Championship
No. 2 St. Thomas 9, No. 4 Dayton 7
2020 – NO TOURNAMENT
2021 – NO TOURNAMENT
2022 – Round Rock, Texas
First Round
No. 1 St. Thomas 12, No. 16 Florida Atlantic 4
No. 15 UNC-Charlotte 17, No. 15 College of Idaho 16 (ot)
No. 14 Cal State San Marcos 14, No. 3 Kennesaw State 6
No. 4 Grand Valley State 16, No. 13 UC San Diego 11
No. 5 Utah 9, No. 12 North Dakota State 8
No. 6 Montana 9, No. 11 Florida Gulf Coast 8
No. 7 Rhode Island 16, No. 10 Utah State 15 (ot)
No. 9 Missouri State 13, No. 8 Montana State 8
Quarterfinals
No. 1 St. Thomas 9, No. 9 Missouri State 6
No. 7 Rhode Island 15, No. 15 UNC-Charlotte 7
No. 6 Montana 13, No. 14 Cal State San Marcos 9
No. 5 Utah 13, No. 4 Grand Valley State 7
Semifinals
No. 5 Utah 7, No. 1 St. Thomas 6
No. 7 Rhode Island 15, No. 6 Montana 7
Championship
No. 5 Utah 13, No. 7 Rhode Island 7
2023 – Round Rock, Texas
First Round
No. 1 Rhode Island 20, No. 16 North Dakota State 8
No. 2 Cal State San Marcos 11, No. 15 Minn.-Duluth 6
No. 3 St. Thomas 13, Florida Atlantic 8
No. 13 Air Force Academy 16, No. 4 Montana 14
No. 12 UNC-Charlotte 15, No. 5 Missouri State 14
No. 6 Montana State 16, No. 11 UC San Diego 8
No. 7 Grand Valley State 11, No. 10 Florida Gulf Coast 7
No. 9 Dayton 15, No. 8 Kennesaw State 9
Quarterfinals
No. 9 Dayton 14, No. 1 Rhode Island 6
No. 2 Cal State San Marcos 13, No. 7 Grand Valley State 11
No. 3 St. Thomas 14, No. 6 Montana State 4
No. 13 Air Force Academy 16, No. 12 UNC-Charlotte 13
Semifinals
No. 9 Dayton 11, No. 13 Air Force Academy 10
No. 3 St. Thomas 11, No. 2 Cal State San Marcos 4
Championship
No. 9 Dayton 6, No. 3 St. Thomas 5
Tournament Appearances
| Team | Years Appeared | Record | Pct. |
| Air Force Academy | 2023 | 2-1 | .667 |
| Augustana* | 2006 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Briarcliffe | 2010-13, 2015 | 1-5 | .167 |
| Bridgewater State | 2016-17, 2019 | 0-3 | .000 |
| UC Irvine | 2007 | 0-1 | .000 |
| UC Santa Cruz | 2008 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Cal State Fullerton | 2009-11, 2015, 2017-18 | 0-6 | .000 |
| Cal State San Marcos | 2018, 2022-23 | 3-3 | .500 |
| Calvin* | 2005-06 | 0-2 | .000 |
| Central Conn. State | 2018 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Claremont% | 2006 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Coast Guard* | 2013-14 | 1-2 | .333 |
| College of Idaho | 2018-19-22 | 2-3 | .400 |
| Concordia-Irvine | 2012-17 | 8-5 | .615 |
| Davenport% | 2009-12 | 9-3 | .750 |
| Davidson | 2005 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Dayton | 2007-12, 2014-19, 2023 | 26-11 | .703 |
| DePaul | 2013 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Eckerd | 2006 | 2-1 | .667 |
| Elon% | 2008, 2010, 2012 | 1-3 | .250 |
| Emory | 2007, 2009 | 2-2 | .500 |
| Florida Atlantic | 2022-23 | 0-2 | .000 |
| Florida Gulf Coast | 2014-15, 2017-18, 2022-23 | 2-6 | .250 |
| Fort Lewis | 2007-08 | 0-2 | .000 |
| Framingham State | 2008 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Grand Canyon% | 2012 | 1-1 | .500 |
| Grand Valley State | 2008, 2010-19-23 | 23-12 | .657 |
| Grove City* | 2010, 2013-16 | 3-5 | .375 |
| Harding | 2005-08 | 2-4 | .333 |
| Hope* | 2011 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Indiana Tech$ | 2013-14 | 2-2 | .500 |
| Kennesaw State | 2015-16, 2018-19-23 | 2-6 | .250 |
| Liberty% | 2013 | 2-1 | .667 |
| Louisiana | 2017 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Lourdes$ | 2016 | 1-1 | .500 |
| Metro State | 2017 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Minn.-Duluth& | 2016-19, 2023 | 4-5 | .444 |
| Missouri Baptist$ | 2011 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Missouri State | 2009-10, 2017-19-23 | 1-6 | .143 |
| Missouri Valley$ | 2014-16 | 0-3 | .000 |
| Montana@ | 2005-07, 2017, 2019-23 | 8-6 | .571 |
| Montana State | 2014, 2016, 2018, 2022-23 | 2-6 | .250 |
| North Dakota State | 2011-19-23 | 13-10 | .565 |
| North Florida | 2019 | 1-1 | .500 |
| Northern Arizona | 2019 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Northern Colorado | 2006-07, 2009, 2011 | 3-4 | .429 |
| Palm Beach Atlantic* | 2013, 2017 | 0-2 | .000 |
| Reinhardt$ | 2014, 2016 | 2-2 | .500 |
| Rhode Island | 2022-23 | 4-2 | .667 |
| St. Mary's (Calif.) | 2012 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Sam Houston State | 2010-13 | 0-4 | .000 |
| San Diego# | 2005-06 | 6-0 | 1.000 |
| SCAD$ | 2010-14 | 1-5 | .167 |
| Siena Heights$ | 2015-16 | 1-2 | .333 |
| Sierra Nevada | 2015-18 | 1-4 | .200 |
| Southern Oregon | 2016 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Southwestern* | 2005-09 | 1-5 | .167 |
| St. John's | 2005-15, 2017-19 | 18-14 | .563 |
| St. Thomas | 2006-19-23 | 42-10 | .808 |
| Stonehill | 2009 | 0-1 | .000 |
| UC Davis | 2018-19 | 0-2 | .000 |
| UC San Diego | 2019-23 | 0-3 | .000 |
| UNC-Charlotte | 2022-23 | 2-2 | .500 |
| Utah ** | 2022 | 4-0 | 1.000 |
| Utah State% | 2015, 2019-22 | 0-3 | .000 |
| Utah Valley% | 2005-06, 2010-11 | 5-4 | .556 |
| Washington-St. Louis | 2002 | 0-1 | .000 |
| Western Oregon | 2008-14 | 3-7 | .300 |
| Western Washington | 2007, 2010, 2014-15 | 2-4 | .333 |
| Westminster* | 2007-13 | 12-6 | .667 |
Winner’s Bracket Games Only
* - indicates program now playing in the NCAA
% - indicates team now an MCLA Div. I program
^ - Does not include record from MCLA Div. I Championships (pre-2005)
# - indicates team returning to MCLA Div. II in 2016
& - indicates team that moved to MCLA Div. II in 2016 from Div. I
$ - indicates team now playing in NAIA
@ - indicates team returning to MCLA Div. II in 2017
** - returned to MCLA in 2022 as sub-varsity, moved to MCLA-I in 2023